Welcome to Annie W. Metzler Insurance, Inc....


Whether you need a car insurance or homeowner's insurance policy, need coverage for your business or want to protect your farm and livestock, one thing is certain. You probably don't know that much about insurance, except what you've seen in TV commercials. And all the hype about getting the best price really isn't worth a whole lot, if you don't have the coverage you need in the end.

What really matters is getting the RIGHT coverage and the BEST protection for your money. At Annie Metzler Insurance agency we don't just offer insurance policies. We take care of people and their families.

In today's fast-paced world we think it's still important to know our customers by name, get to know them and ask the right questions to really find out what insurance coverage they need. We don't just take down a few numbers and give you a quote. We take the time to really understand your situation and recommend the RIGHT coverage for you.

We're your small, neighborhood agency that always has time for questions, looks over your policies every year to see if they are still working for you and works with you when you have a claim or an issue. So if you're looking for an insurance policy, take down that number the next time you see a TV commercial. If you're looking for an agent that takes the time to get to know you, we'd love to talk with you.

Call our office at (717) 786-5411 or toll free at (855) 648-5411 to get answers to all your questions and start a relationship that only gets better with the passage of time!


2013 Referral Contest Results

Our quarterly winners for the gift cards were Theresa Graham, Adam Bilheimer, and Travis and Ashley Harnish.


Our Grand Prize winner was Brandy Gore. Pictured here is Brandy and her children, along with agency Principal Kevin Kreider, picking up her LG flat screen.











Address: 175 Oak Bottom Road • Quarryville, PA 17566 • Local: (717) 786-5411 • Toll Free: (855) 648-5411 • Email:

©2014, Annie W. Metzler Insurance, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Website Design & Hosting By EZSolution Corp.