Business Hours: 8am - 5pm Monday-Friday (or by appointment)

Claims / Companies



*If the claim occurs during our normal business hours please contact our office directly by phone at either our
local (717)786-5411 or our toll free (855) 648-5411.


Agency Insurance Co.www.agencyinsurancecompany.comClaims: 1-800-841-5241
Brethren Mutual Insurance Company www.bmic.comAfter Hours Claims: 1-800-241-2541
Cumberland Insurance Group www.cumberlandgroup.comClaims: 1-800-222-4413
Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Company / 1st Choice Autowww.everettcash.comAfter Hours Auto Claims: 1-866-752-6331
After Hours Work Comp: 1-866-469-6282
Frederick Mutual Insurance Co.www.fredmut.comClaims: 1-866-212-5246
Goodville Mutual Casualty Co.www.goodville.comClaims: 1-877-445-5780
Kemper Preferredwww.kemper.comClaims: 1-888-252-2799
Lititz Mutual Insurance Companywww.lititzmutual.comClaims: 1-855-725-5642
Millville Mutual Insurance Companywww.millvillemutual.comAfter Hours Claims: 1-800-262-8495
Nationwide / Alliedwww.nationwide.comClaims: 1-800-421-3535
Progressive Insurance Co.www.driveinsurance.comClaims: 1-800-925-2886





Address: 175 Oak Bottom Road • Quarryville, PA 17566 • Local: (717) 786-5411 • Toll Free: (855) 648-5411 • Email:

© 2017, Annie W. Metzler Insurance Agency, Inc. All Rights Reserved.     View Privacy Policy.