Metzler Insurance Logo

If the claim occurs during our normal business hours please contact our office directly by phone at 717-786-6005.


Business Hours: 8am – 4:30pm Monday-Friday (or by appointment)

Our Partner Insurance Associates:

Agency Insurance Co.

agencyinsurancecompany.com
Claims:
1-800-841-5241

Brethren Mutual Insurance Company

bmic.com
After Hours Claims:
1-800-241-2541

Cumberland Insurance Group

cumberlandgroup.com
Claims:
1-800-222-4413

Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Company / 1st Choice Auto

everettcash.com
After Hours Auto Claims:
1-866-752-6331

After Hours Work Comp:
1-866-469-6282

Goodville Mutual Casualty Co.

goodville.com
Claims:
1-877-445-5780

Millville Mutual Insurance Company

millvillemutual.com
After Hours Claims:
1-800-262-8495

Nationwide / Allied

nationwide.com
Claims:
1-800-421-3535

Progressive Insurance Co.

driveinsurance.com
Claims:
1-800-925-2886

Annie Metzler Insurance Agency

Physical Address:
175 Oak Bottom Road, Quarryville, PA 17566

Mailing Address:
P.O. Box 322, Quarryville, PA 17566

Phone: 717-786-6005
Fax: 717-786-6004

Email: info@metzlerinsurance.com

Copyright © 2024. All Rights Reserved. Annie Metzler Insurance Agency.

Annie Metzler Insurance values your privacy and is committed to protecting your personal information. We understand the importance of safeguarding the data you provide to us and maintaining your trust.

Trusted Choice logo
IAB Proud Member Logo